Page 6 of 6

Re: MSU @ Ind State (12 PM Sat)

PostPosted: January 8th, 2012, 3:59 pm
by glm38
MSUBears wrote:In my opinion, Odem's foul on the break away at the end of the game was no more or no less intentional than the one called on Sheer in the first half - and both fouls were called by the same ref. I don't care how he calls them but he should have been consistent. While it did not happen in this game, nothing worse than a ref's inconsistency determining a game.


Unfortunately I think that's just typical Valley officiating. It's rarely in one team's favor (which is good) but the inconsistency can drive us (and I'm sure the coaches and players) crazy.

Re: MSU @ Ind State (12 PM Sat)

PostPosted: January 8th, 2012, 5:16 pm
by DoubleJayAlum
glm38 wrote:
MSUBears wrote:In my opinion, Odem's foul on the break away at the end of the game was no more or no less intentional than the one called on Sheer in the first half - and both fouls were called by the same ref. I don't care how he calls them but he should have been consistent. While it did not happen in this game, nothing worse than a ref's inconsistency determining a game.


Unfortunately I think that's just typical Valley officiating. It's rarely in one team's favor (which is good) but the inconsistency can drive us (and I'm sure the coaches and players) crazy.


LMAO - I agree. If there is one thing you can say about the refs we seem to get for the most part, it is that they are consistently inconsistent.

Re: MSU @ Ind State (12 PM Sat)

PostPosted: January 8th, 2012, 7:23 pm
by BearChief
MSUBears wrote:In my opinion, Odem's foul on the break away at the end of the game was no more or no less intentional than the one called on Sheer in the first half - and both fouls were called by the same ref. I don't care how he calls them but he should have been consistent. While it did not happen in this game, nothing worse than a ref's inconsistency determining a game.


Really?

Scheer went to grab the player around the body while he was still on the floor. He didn't make any attempt at the ball. BIG difference. There is a difference between a hard foul and an intentional foul.

Re: MSU @ Ind State (12 PM Sat)

PostPosted: January 8th, 2012, 9:02 pm
by beatingrillz
Under the new rules they both were flagrant, however lusk has to ask go the review on the hit to the head. Odum is quickly becoming an average player and it is frustrating to him and the fans.

Re: MSU @ Ind State (12 PM Sat)

PostPosted: January 10th, 2012, 11:08 am
by troutangler
beatingrillz wrote:Under the new rules they both were flagrant, however lusk has to ask go the review on the hit to the head. Odum is quickly becoming an average player and it is frustrating to him and the fans.


You need to learn what a flagrant foul is, because neither were flagrant.

Re: MSU @ Ind State (12 PM Sat)

PostPosted: January 10th, 2012, 1:35 pm
by MSUBear42
troutangler wrote:
beatingrillz wrote:Under the new rules they both were flagrant, however lusk has to ask go the review on the hit to the head. Odum is quickly becoming an average player and it is frustrating to him and the fans.


You need to learn what a flagrant foul is, because neither were flagrant.

Maybe your Junior High games have different rules, but both fouls were flagrant.

An example of a Flagrant 1 foul would be a player who swings an elbow and makes non-excessive contact with an opponent above the shoulders. The team whose player was struck would receive two free throws and possession of the ball.




An example of a Flagrant 2 foul would be a player who swings an elbow excessively and makes contact with an opponent above the shoulders. In this case, the player who threw the elbow would be ejected from the game, and the other team would receive two free throws and the ball