Wufan wrote:BirdsEyeView wrote:Wufan wrote:
Whether on not McIntosh is a better player than Johnson is a different argument than if you would trade for him.
What do you mean? Same graduating class. Nearly the same position...McIntosh can play #1-#4
So, with those being rather equal...now, you are arguing value over replacement player or value added/lost in trading the two players. If Alize Johnson is on ISUr and McIntosh is on MSU. How much better or worse is either team?
If someone is on your team, and is "your guy", then you might not want to trade him even if there is an upgrade in talent. As a fan, you enjoy watching the intricacies of your guy, and that's it. You fall in love, and even though you recognize the qualities in other players, it's just not the same.
I don't think I would trade Darrell Brown for anyone else in the conference right now for the reasons Wufan listed.