Milwaukee has to show more than what they have outside of the Bo Ryan and Bruce Pearl days. After reclassifying to DI, they were absolute garbage in the 1990's, and under Jeter, they were a 4th place Horizon team at best.
Good school, well-resourced and competitive in recent years, but they were lucky for a stretch of 7 or so years. But outside of that, woof.
I can live with them because they aren't terrible, but I'm not convinced they're as good as they appear. If I had to take another Horizon team, I'd put Wright and even Northern Kentucky at the top of the list well before Milwaukee.