WuDrWu wrote:Khan4Cats wrote:So your basically agreeing with him that Ahelegbe would be a bigger loss.
As for the other players, we certainly know that we can't expect much from our reserves, seeing as they were 'boat-raced' everytime they came in last year.
By the way, the starting line-up will likely be Ahelegbe, Moran (both two-year starters), Dunham (a 5th-year senior who started most of the games as a Fr), Koch and then a question between O'Rear, Rank, and Austin Pehl. If it's O'Rear, the line-up will have 3 seniors, a junior and a sophomore-exactly the same mix as last year.
Actually, what I am saying is that it doesn't take a stretch at all to see UNI battling to stay out of the playin game. But, it seems that more than 1 Pantherfan is convinced that the 3 departing seniors were not all that integral in the success of the team as a whole, or players as specifics. They were just parts to be switched out for the next. Interchangeable links in a permanent fence of champions. Like Duke, UNI just reloads.
No lower than first or second from the Panthers for the foreseeable future.
It
is a stretch to say that UNI could be in the play in round. We lost some spectacular players, but still return a whole lot of experience. Lets be realistic here...
And I'm glad Khan brought up the 'boat raced' comment. As we all know, you were the guy that proclaimed that UNI's second 5 would be boat raced by most of the Valley. That was only a week or two before that very group abused the shockers starting 5 in the MVC title game. So we already know how much respect you have for the players on the UNI roster. Those are the same young players that we will return this year.
UNI's starting 5 next year will have as much experience coming back as almost any other team, and they have championship experience. And they will continue to use 4-5 guys off of the bench to go 9-10 players deep.
As was mentioned, anyone can play the "what if this guy gets inured" game with any team. If you take a valuable player or a starting PG off of any team, they will be a much different team. UNI is no different than any other team in that regard.
Nobody has said that UNI is going to roll through the valley again. If fact, I haven't seen a single person predict UNI to win the MVC next year. Fact is, with the team that UNI brings back, they are a lock to be a solid team and an easy choice to be top 5 again.